|
|
|
IRRA Executive Board
Dinner and Meeting
Thursday, January 6, 2005, 6:15 p.m.
Philadelphia North Room, Wyndham Philadelphia
at Franklin Plaza
17th and Race Street, Philadelphia PA
Call to Order„The meeting was called to order at 7:20 p.m. by President
Marlene Heyser. Present at the meeting were officers Marlene Heyser
(president), Stephen R. Sleigh (president elect), Paula B. Voos (past president),
Pete Feuille (secretary-treasurer), Adrienne Eaton (editor-in-chief),
Lavonne Ritter (NCAC), and members Peter Berg, Jackie Blanchard, Dan
Cornfield, Joel Cutcher-Gershenfeld, Andy Levin, Anthony Oliver, Robert
Taylor, John Truesdale, and Art Schwartz. Other invited guests included
board-elect members Sara Adler, Paul Almeida, Morris Kleiner, and Jill
Kriesky; president elect-elect David Lipsky; and committee chairs and coordinators
Jim Auerbach, John Burton, Ralph Craviso, Charles Whalen, Hoyt
Wheeler, and Greg Woodhead. Board members not able to attend included
Nancy Biagini, Amy Dean, Ann Frost, Sanford Jacoby, and Wilma Liebman.
National office staff present included Paula Wells, Sarah Dolinar, and Anna
Mehl.
Award Recognition and Announcements„Marlene Heyser recognized
outgoing board members Dan Cornfield, John Truesdale, Art Schwartz,
Nancy Biagini, and Sandy Jacoby. Newly elected board members whose terms
will begin following the 2005 annual meeting were also recognized: Paul
Almeida, Department of Professional Employees, AFL-CIO; Morris Kleiner,
University of Minnesota; Sara Adler, arbitrator/mediator; Jill Kriesky,
Appalachian Institute at Wheeling Jesuit University; and Jerry Calhoun,
Boeing Commercial Airplanes.
It was announced that a letter of resignation from board member Wilma
Liebman had been received and that she would be stepping down from her position on the IRRA/LERA board because of a new federal policy stating
that presidential appointees could not serve on certain types of boards. A
neutral replacement will be named at a future date to serve out the remaining
year of her term.
President elect Steve Sleigh recognized Marlene Heyser for her service
as the 2004 IRRA president.
Marlene Heyser recognized Greg Woodhead for his eight years of service
as chair of the LERA Finance and Membership Committee.
Approval of Minutes --A motion was heard to approve the minutes of the
Chicago, IL, board meeting on June 1, 2004. It was seconded and unanimously
approved
Committee and Officer Reports
æææææNominating Committee Report„„Chair Ralph Craviso reported the slate
of candidates on behalf of the Nominating Committee. The 2004 committee
included Janice Bellace, William Canak, Rachel Hendrickson, Dennis Rocheleau,
Jay Siegel, and Paula B. Voos. Craviso announce Eileen Hoffman as
unanimous selection of the 2006 president-elect position. A motion was
made to accept the slate of candidates presented and was seconded (Ritter).
The motion passed unanimously. Perspectives on Work Editorial Advisory Board Report„Charles
Whalen, editor and chair, reported the current state of the Perspectives magazine
and announced that the magazine has asked two guest coeditors, Jim
Auerbach and David Jacobs, to collaborate with him on the winter 2006
issue. He reported the launch of the Perspectives Online Companion, an
online expansion of each issue, had taken place in the fall of 2004 and will be
updated on a biannual basis.
Foundations Committee„ John Burton announced that the meeting was
cancelled and therefore had nothing to report. It was noted the committee is
currently without a chair.
Education Committee—Because the committee meeting was delayed
until Friday, no report was given at this meeting.
Sections and Councils Committee„Joel Cutcher-Gershenfeld, cochair,
gave a report on the Industry Councils, in which he noted that 482 people have
signed up for Industry Councils, and 83 of them became new members of the
Association because of their interest in the councils. He summarized the role and objectives of the councils, an initiative enabled by a grant from the Alfred
P. Sloan Foundation and asked board members to review the proposed charters
for three councils: Aerospace, Airline, and Public Sector-Federal.
He made a motion to accept the charters of Aerospace, Airlines and Public
Sector-Federal as submitted and sanction the first three LERA Industry
Councils. Comments were made to recognize the hard work of those behind
the councils and of their importance and relevance to LERA. The motion
was passed unanimously.
Hoyt Wheeler, cochair, reported on the LERA Interest Sections, summarizing
their roles and activities, including conducting surveys, convening meetings,
distributing e-mail newsletters and listservs, and developing bylaws. A
question was heard on the role of the sections regarding the development of
the annual meeting, to which Hoyt explained that sections are invited to submit
proposals for sessions or workshops. A suggestion was heard to reserve
slots in the program for sections, to which it was noted that the annual meeting
is already a very tight program and that it would be difficult to make such
a policy; in addition, doing so might involve needing to amend association
bylaws, because current bylaws called for the president, cochairs, and committee
to determine the program.
Together, the cochairs brought a motion from the committee to split the
Sections and Councils Coordinating Committee and create separate coordinating
committees for both areas. Hoyt would chair the Sections Coordinating
Committee, and Cutcher-Gershenfeld would chair the Councils Coordinating
Committee. It was noted that the recommendation did not include adding a
position to the board and that each committee would make individual
reports to the board. Cutcher-Gershenfeld and Hoyt would be responsible as
chairs to reconstitute the committees and recruit members. The motion was
seconded and passed unanimously.
Development Committee„ David Lipsky, chair, reported on the history
of the committee, noting the creation of subcommittees that focus on specific
fundraising efforts and research. He brought forward the following
motions from the committee for the board to consider:
A. Motion„to announce the launch of a three-year development campaign
at the 2006 annual meeting, the goal of which will be $1 million. The
campaign will run from January 2006 to January 2009. A question was heard
on plans to endow any of the $1 million raised by the campaign, to which
Lipsky reported the Development Committee has discussed the benefits and
disadvantages of endowed funds with attention paid to the mission and projections
of the association and the administration of endowment accounts,
but there were no formal recommendations from the committee at this time. The primary focus for raising the funds, he noted, is to ensure the continued
operation of the association. He did point out that the campaign will involve
various giving opportunities, including naming opportunities, restricted gifts,
et cetera. The motion was passed unanimously.
B. Motion„That LERA impose a 10 percent administrative fee on all
such gifts, including the Susan C. Eaton Fund, to cover the operational and
administrative costs of development and administration of such funds. This
was passed unanimously.
C. Motion„Lipsky reported on the Susan C. Eaton Scholar-Practitioner
Fund and recognized and acknowledged the efforts of Tom Kochan to raise
approximately $50,000 for the fund. He reported that the committee recommended
that LERA not put the $50,000 in an endowment, but rather create
a small committee to administer the fund to be able to give annual monetary
awards to deserving scholar-practitioners. The fund would be managed to
allocate all the monies within a finite period of time, such as ten to fifteen
years, and that the time period should only be extended should more money
be given for the award. It was also recommended that a member of the
Finance and Membership Committee be a member of this subcommittee.
The motion passed unanimously.
D. Motion„To create an annual solicitation process that would be
included in the regular renewal application as a list of tiered check-off
options for additional contribution amounts, giving members an opportunity
to give above and beyond their membership dues. The motion was passed
unanimously.
Lipsky asked the board to review and make comments offline on a draft
of the LERA case statement, which will be circulated soon to the board. He
described the case statement as a rationale of the campaign that might
encourage donors to support LERA. He also asked the board to consider and
give feedback on some of the logistics of the campaign, including fundraising
targets, activities, and audiences and invited board members to take part in
the Development Committee activities and planning. In addition, he asked
that, by the time LERA announces the capital campaign in January 2006,
that he be able to report 100 percent board participation in fundraising
efforts.
Finally, there was discussion regarding the idea to create a LERA Foundation,
a nonprofit body that would administer the fundraising efforts and
gifts. The committee agreed to consider the idea in a future meeting.
Finance and Membership Committee„ Chair Greg Woodhead reported
on the 2004 financial report, including the estimated year-end membership
dues revenues of $142,044 and the grants received revenues of $221,547. He pointed out the association appears to be grant dependent. He summarized
the membership report, including the 2004 membership totals of 2,871. He
also reported that the committee discussed joint membership options. It was
noted that local chapters are not in favor of joint memberships but that they
are researching unified membership structure. He presented the following
motions from committee:
A. Motion„to approve the 2005 budget as presented. A second was
heard. The motion passed unanimously.
B. Motion„to raise the annual membership dues effective January 2006.
The annual regular membership dues would be raised from $95 to $105; the
emeritus membership dues would be raised from $55 to $60; library subscriptions
would be raised from $175 to $190; student memberships would
remain at $25. The motion passed unanimously.
Woodhead asked that, in the coming year, board members continue the
practice of making five personal contacts (by e-mail or phone) to members as
a way to encourage membership renewals.
Report of the Secretary/Treasurer and Executive Director„ Peter Feuille,
secretary-treasurer, reported that the financial situation of the association
cannot be taken care of by simply cutting expenditures and commended the
staff for managing the expenditures. He reported that progress was made
this year in understanding what is involved in development and fundraising
efforts and acknowledged the work of the Development Committee. He
acknowledged that the three-year Sloan Foundation grant has been much
needed by the association in creating programs that would interest new
members.
Paula Wells, executive director, summarized the financial and membership
reports that were provided, and answered questions from the board.
Her summary included a profile of the year, highlighted primarily by the
addition of new staff, activities surrounding the name change the development
of new LERA Industry Councils and the reactivation of the National
Policy Forum in the FMCS's NLMC last June. A comment was heard regarding
the information and data base systems ith which the national staff
works, and a suggestion was made for the board to help in some way. Wells
welcomed such an exploration of the database system and possible solutions.
A suggestion was also heard that the association might consider increasing
the expenditures for membership development.
NCAC Committee„ Lavonne Ritter, NCAC chair, reported that the
committee discussed changes to the chapter awards process and nomination
form and passed several recommendations, including a general request for more supporting material to accompany nominations; clarifying descriptive
language for each award and suggested supporting material; adding specific
wording stating that, once a chapter wins a Chapter Star Award, its record
again restarts again at zero.
Discussion was heard on chapter dues status, showing that seven chapters
are in arrears on their dues to national. The committee elected to place
the Greater Cincinnati chapter on inactive status rather than revoking its
charter. They discussed a dues waiver request from the Gold Rush Chapter,
but did not approve the waiver, requesting more information instead. The
committee reported three chapter grants dispersed in 2004, and one grant
was moved to the 2005 budget. NCAC members Talmage Reynolds and
Matthew Bodah have been reappointed to serve on the committee for threeyear
terms, ending 2008.
A request was made for the board to consider approving the imposition
of a deadline for chapters to pay their dues to national. A motion was heard
that national use stronger wording clearly stating to chapters that by being in
arrears on dues to national that they are "jeopardizing their tax-exempt status."
A second was heard. The motion was passed unanimously.
A suggestion was heard from the board to communicate the pending capital
campaign to chapters and to include for consideration of a chapter to
National Merit Award the criteria of higher percentages of individual memberships
in the national association as well as contribution to the campaign.
NCAC was requested to encourage chapters to provide their members' contact
information to national. Lavonne Ritter suggested that the Development
Committee consider a solicitation of chapters for the campaign as well
as annual gifts.
Editorial Committee„Adrienne Eaton, editor-in-chief, reported that the
committee discussed the 2005 research volume, which will be focused on
ethics. Although they do not have a proposal for the 2006 research volume
ready to present to the board at this time, they did review a list of chapters
and authors suggested by David Lewin. The view of the committee is that
this volume is looking like a review of contemporary issues in industrial relations
and that it will be recommended that the board approve by e-mail the
forthcoming proposal. Suggestions for future volumes included a volume on
retirement issues.
National Policy Forum 2005„James A. Auerbach, NPF 2005 meeting
coordinator, gave a brief report on the plans for the program, which will take
place June 16¿17, 2005, at the Hotel Washington in Washington, D.C. The theme of the event will be "Benefits at Risk: Meeting the Challenge of Providing
Health Care Benefits and Retirement Income in the 21st Century."
Financial support, in the form of sponsorships and individual gift solicitations
is being sought for the meeting. Joe Hanson of the UFCW and Bill Vaughn of
Ahold USA have been named as conference cochairs. Steve Sleigh noted that
at this time the committee is securing very high-profile plenary speakers.
Program Committee 58th Annual Meeting„Stephen R. Sleigh, president
elect and program chair, reported that Ralph Craviso and Richard Freeman
have agreed to cochair the committee. The program will take place
January 5¿8, 2006, in Boston, MA. The theme will be "Labor and Capital in
the 21st Century: Human, Social, and Financial Contributions to Creating
Wealth."
New Business
TERRA News„John Burton summarized the history of TERRA News,
an e-mail distribution list of news and information relevant to TERRA members,
and summarized the history of the creation of IRRA News, a weekly
e-mail listserv repackaged from the daily TERRA News program. Burton reported
that the board originally approved the IRRA News program pending
successful fundraising to cover the expenses. That fundraising did not happen,
and in the late fall of 2004, the IRRA News service was terminated.
TERRA News will continue to be operated by the TERRA chapter for its
members. The national office publicized TERRA News subscriptions to the
LERA listservs when IRRA News service was terminated.
2004 Awards Report„Paula Wells, executive director, acknowledged the
2004 award winners, including Lifetime Achievement Award winners Walter
Gershenfeld and Kenneth Ristau, who will be recognized at the Presidential
Luncheon. All other awards will be given at the general membership meeting.
Chapter awards will be given at the NCAC/chapter representatives meeting.
IRRA Awards Committee Proposal„Morris Kleiner, IRRA Awards
Committee member, put forth a motion from the committee that the board
change the name of the Outstanding Young Scholar Award to the John T.
Dunlop Scholar Award as a tribute to the IRRA cofounder who passed away
in 2004. A question was heard regarding the limitations of the age or stage of
award winner. Morris explained that the award criteria suggested that nominees
be within ten years of the completion of their Ph.D. but does not indicate
any age limitations. The motion passed unanimously.
Other Business
Ratify Constitution with LERA Name Change„Paula Wells, executive
director, presented the modified constitution and bylaws to the board for ratification,
noting the only changes in the document were in the four places
where the association's name was stated. In those four places, the former
name of Labor and Employment Relations Association or IRRA, was changed to
Labor and Employment Relations Association, or LERA. This is in compliance
with previous board vote and the vote of the general membership by
mail in June 2004.
A motion was heard to ratify the constitution and bylaws with the new
name for the organization: Labor and Employment Research Association, or
LERA. The motion was seconded and passed unanimously.
Meeting Adjournment
--The meeting was adjourned at 10:27 p.m.
|